The growth of the underground
economy, also known as the informal or shadow economy, is influenced by various socioeconomic factors. These factors can be categorized into three main dimensions: economic, social, and institutional. Understanding these factors is crucial for policymakers and researchers to develop effective strategies to mitigate the size and impact of the underground economy.
1. Economic Factors:
a) High Tax Burden: One of the primary economic factors driving the underground economy is a high tax burden. When tax rates are excessively high, individuals and businesses may resort to informal activities to avoid or evade
taxes. This is particularly true in countries where tax compliance costs are burdensome and tax systems are complex.
b) Lack of Access to Formal Employment: Limited job opportunities and high levels of
unemployment or
underemployment can push individuals towards informal activities as a means of survival. In economies with high levels of poverty and
income inequality, the underground economy often serves as a safety net for those unable to find formal employment.
c) Economic Crisis and
Recession: During times of economic crisis or recession, formal sectors may experience a decline, leading to increased participation in the underground economy. Individuals who lose their jobs or face reduced income may turn to informal activities as a means of sustaining their livelihoods.
2. Social Factors:
a) Social Norms and Attitudes: Societal acceptance or tolerance towards informal activities can significantly influence the growth of the underground economy. In some cultures or communities, engaging in informal transactions may be seen as a survival strategy or a way to bypass bureaucratic hurdles. These social norms and attitudes can perpetuate the existence of the underground economy.
b) Trust
Deficit: In societies where there is a lack of trust in formal institutions, individuals may be more inclined to participate in the underground economy. This lack of trust can stem from corruption, weak governance, or a perception that formal institutions do not adequately serve the needs of the population.
c) Informal Networks and Social Capital: Informal networks and social capital play a crucial role in the growth of the underground economy. These networks facilitate the
exchange of goods and services outside formal channels, relying on personal relationships and trust. Informal networks can provide access to resources, information, and opportunities that are not available through formal channels.
3. Institutional Factors:
a) Regulatory Burden: Excessive regulations, bureaucratic red tape, and complex legal frameworks can create barriers for individuals and businesses to operate in the formal economy. When compliance costs are high or regulations are burdensome, participants may choose to operate in the underground economy to avoid these obstacles.
b) Weak Law Enforcement: Inadequate law enforcement and weak institutional capacity to detect and deter informal activities can contribute to the growth of the underground economy. When there is a perception of low
risk and impunity, individuals and businesses are more likely to engage in informal transactions.
c) Lack of Social Protection: Limited access to social protection programs, such as unemployment benefits, healthcare, or retirement schemes, can drive individuals towards the underground economy. In the absence of formal safety nets, individuals may turn to informal activities as a means of securing their economic well-being.
In conclusion, the growth of the underground economy is influenced by a complex interplay of socioeconomic factors. Economic factors such as high tax burdens and limited formal employment opportunities, social factors including social norms and trust deficits, and institutional factors like regulatory burden and weak law enforcement all contribute to the expansion of the underground economy. Addressing these factors requires a comprehensive approach that combines effective taxation policies, improved governance, enhanced social protection systems, and efforts to foster trust in formal institutions.