The issue of double taxation on international income is a significant concern for individuals and businesses engaged in cross-border transactions. Double taxation occurs when two or more countries impose
taxes on the same income or capital, leading to a potential decrease in after-tax profits and discouraging international investment and trade. To mitigate this issue, various methods have been developed to avoid or minimize double taxation. In this chapter, we will explore some key methods used to address this problem.
1. Bilateral Tax Treaties:
Bilateral tax treaties are agreements between two countries that aim to prevent or alleviate double taxation. These treaties typically allocate taxing rights between the countries involved, specify the types of income that can be taxed, and provide mechanisms for resolving disputes. By clarifying the tax obligations of taxpayers operating in both countries, bilateral tax treaties help to eliminate or reduce the
risk of double taxation.
2.
Foreign Tax Credit:
The foreign tax credit is a mechanism employed by many countries to relieve taxpayers from double taxation. Under this method, a taxpayer who has paid taxes on foreign income can claim a credit against their domestic tax
liability for the amount of tax paid to the foreign country. This ensures that the taxpayer is not taxed twice on the same income. The foreign tax credit is often subject to certain limitations and conditions, such as a cap on the amount of credit that can be claimed.
3. Exemption Method:
The exemption method is an alternative approach to avoiding double taxation. Under this method, a country exempts certain types of foreign income from taxation altogether. For example, a country may choose to exempt dividends received from foreign subsidiaries or capital gains derived from the sale of foreign assets. By exempting specific categories of income, the country effectively eliminates the possibility of double taxation on those items.
4. Tax Treaties' Tiebreaker Rules:
In cases where an individual or
business is considered a resident of two countries under their respective tax laws, conflicts may arise regarding the determination of tax residency. Tax treaties often include tiebreaker rules to resolve such conflicts. These rules typically consider factors such as the individual's permanent home, center of vital interests, habitual abode, and nationality. By providing clear criteria for determining tax residency, tiebreaker rules help prevent double taxation resulting from conflicting residency claims.
5. Transfer Pricing:
Transfer pricing refers to the pricing of goods, services, or intellectual property transferred between related entities in different tax jurisdictions. To avoid double taxation, countries require that transfer prices be set at arm's length, meaning they should reflect the price that would have been agreed upon by unrelated parties in a similar transaction. By ensuring that profits are allocated appropriately between related entities, transfer pricing rules help prevent double taxation resulting from inconsistent
profit allocations.
6. Holding Companies and Tax Havens:
Some businesses establish holding companies in jurisdictions with favorable tax regimes or tax havens to minimize their overall tax liability. By routing income through these entities, businesses can take advantage of lower tax rates or tax exemptions offered by these jurisdictions. While this approach can be effective in reducing taxes, it has faced criticism for potentially facilitating
tax avoidance and erosion of the
tax base in other countries.
7. Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs):
APAs are agreements between taxpayers and tax authorities that determine the transfer pricing methodology to be applied for a specific set of transactions over a defined period. By obtaining an APA, taxpayers can proactively establish a mutually agreed transfer pricing arrangement with tax authorities, reducing the risk of double taxation resulting from transfer pricing disputes.
In conclusion, the key methods used to avoid double taxation on international income include bilateral tax treaties, foreign tax credits, exemption methods, tiebreaker rules in tax treaties, transfer pricing regulations, the use of holding companies and tax havens, and the establishment of APAs. These methods aim to provide clarity, consistency, and fairness in the taxation of international income, thereby encouraging cross-border investment and trade while minimizing the negative impact of double taxation.